Dave/Tyler:
The Fstop for your first photo (Claw and water drops) was F3.5 (at 1/320 shutter).
For the second, (tail and claw) it was F3.5 aswell, but shot at 1/400 a stop higher in speed.
Tyler, I like where your going in the second batch of photos. The colour worked well witht he sujects. As for using a larger focal field in the second, I dont think you should have done that, but rather have rotated to the left side of the subject about 45 degrees to have the waterdrop and tail tip in focus.