Supplementation/MBD 1

[MWheelock]

I was planning on waiting to do a write-up for this forum, but maybe it is as good a time as any to discuss MBD and supplementation in depth. I apologize ahead of time that some of this may include advanced medical terms and theory, but I will try to summarize as I go, so that some of the not-so-scientifically minded will know what is being said. I also apologize that this discourse may be disjointed as this is merely a first draft.

Also, this will be broken into 3 sections, because the write up is fairly long. So, here goes…

 

[MWheelock]

2

In the following discourse I will “attempt” to tackle 1) normal chemical values of reptiles (in general terms) and general terminology, 2) how Ca is absorbed and how D3 is synthesized/acquired, 3) how nutritional secondary hyperparathyroidism and renal secondary hyperparathyroidism have to do with this, and 4) the potential for hypercalcemia and possible risks/ cosequenses for oversupplementation.

1) Terminology and general facts-
Calcium has two forms in the blood: ionized and unionized.
Ionized- biologically active (let’s say free floating in the blood- available
for use)
Unionized- bound to proteins (like albumen in the blood) or other
complexes- so, (for our discussion) not actively utilized
(Normally when calcium levels are taken, they refer to the ionized form only. Unionized levels can be calculated by using various formulas and interpretation of other values.)

Many other factors may be involved in getting a correct reading of these levels. Examples- If blood protein (like albumen) is low, there maybe a lower unionized ratio of calcium, and a higher ionized form. If the pH is high, it will decrease the ionized form. (Remember, the body is a complex, ever adjusting system and reference ranges are merely a glimpse of what is going on.)
Parathyroid hormone (PTH) maintains calcium within normal limits by affecting bone resorption, renal calcium excretion, and metablolism of vitamin D.

Calcium to phosphorus ratio- should be 2:1
(Actual reference ranges will/may vary from reptile species to specie sand
subspecies for exact calcium and phosphorus reference ranges - though ratio
between these two chemicals will roughly be 2:1)

Typical Causes of: (to be discussed in later sections)
Hypocalcemia- low serum calcium
-nutritional deficiency- prey or food with an inadequate calcium level.
-impaired absorption- calcium absorption may be impaired by phylates (like soy ingredients), oxalates (spinach), high fat pet foods, acidic foods
-nutritional imbalance- inappropriate calcium to phosphorus ratio in the food eaten.
-renal compromise (kidney’s not working)
-inadequate lighting
Clinical signs- muscle tremors, spontaneous bone fractures, inadequately
calcified eggs
Hypercalcemia- high serum calcium
-primary hyperparathyroidism- parathyroid tumor causing excess excretion of
parathyroid hormones
-oversupplementation- supplements
-nutritional imbalance-foods rich in calcium (rare)
-bone resorption- bone infection or cancer
Clinical signs- Maximal calcium tolerances are likely 3-5 times corresponding minimums. Higher intake may lead to conditioned deficiencies of trace minerals and if combined with high- fat diet, formation of calcium soaps in the digestive tract.
Hyperphosphatemia- high phosphorus
-renal disease
-hypervitaminosis D
-excessive dietary phosphorus
Clinical signs- calcification of the heart and kidney, bone resorption, and
secondary nutritional hyperparathyroidism
Hypophosphatemia- low phosphorus
-starvation
-dietary imbalance
Hypervitaminosis D (too much D3)-
Clinical signs- soft tissue calcification, depression, anorexia, PU/PD, and
weight loss.

2) How D3 is synthesized/acquired-
There are 2 primary methods for obtaining vitamin D3
1) synthesizing it from exposure to ultraviolet B radiation
2) consuming a vertebrate that synthesized the hormone through exposure of the sun.
The production of vitamin D occurs as a result of the photosynthetic conversion of 7-dehydrocholesterol to pre-vitamin D3 (UVB represents the range of light considered important for synthesis of D3.) Pre-vitamin D3 is converted to vitamin D3 via a temperature dependent process. At this point the hormone is transported to the liver where it is hydroxylated to 25-hydroxyvitamin D3. The kidneys serve as the site for the final conversion of the hormone to its active form 1,25-hydroxyvitamin D3 (Calcitriol).

Why is D3 important and how does it relate to calcium?
Vitamin D3 is an essential hormone that plays many different important physiologic roles. Its role in calcium metabolism is probably its most recognized function.

Vitamin D3 stimulates intestinal absorption of both calcium and phosphorus stimulating a rise in blood serum calcium and phosphorus concentrations. Without D3, ingested calcium would not be accessable to the body.

3) That pesky parathyroid-
The parathyroid is an endocrine organ that among other things regulates calcium and phosphorus in the body by turning on an off the production of parathyroid hormone (PTH). It uses various organs, tissues, bone, and a myriad of complex feed-back loops to deal with this regulation.
What we need to know about the parathyroid- If circulating serum calcium levels are low, the parathyroid turns on production of PTH and vitamin D is secreted by the kidney. PTH stimulates osteoclastic activity (break down of bone) to put the calcium and phosphorus in the blood. Vitamin D3 stimulates the intestinal absorption of BOTH calcium and phosphorus, thus raising both concentrations.
PTH also stimulates the kidneys to increase excretion of phosphorus without loosing the calcium. This is important because D3 increases phosphorus absorption and breakdown of bone also increases phosphorus levels.

Metabolic Bone Disease-
This is actually an incomplete term as there are many ways bone disease can be affected by metabolic pathways. The ones that concern us are nutritional secondary hyperparathyroidism and renal secondary hyperparathyroidism.

Nutritional secondary hyperparathyroidism (NSHP)- NSHP is when there is an excessive production of parathyroid hormone (PTH) due to low serum calcium. Either there was (1) no calcium in the diet or, (2) no D3 made or available, so there was no absorption of available calcium in diet. Since no calcium is readily available for intestinal absorption, calcium is resorbed from the bones.
Consequences are weakening of the bones with secondary breaks and abscesses. Since calcium is also required all over the body, weakness, tremors, anorexia are also problems.

Renal secondary hyperparathyroidism (RSHP)- RSHP is a consequence of renal disease and lost kidney function.
Remember- the kidney (among other things) was supposed to 1) synthesize D3 and 2) respond to PTH and excrete excessive phosphorus.
Problem- No D3 No absorption calcium
No D3  the parathyroid continues to stay on to stimulate production of D3. Increasing levels of PTH continue to 1) break down bone and intestinally absorb calcium and phosphorus, but can’t get rid of the phosphorus.
Consequences- if mild, metabolic bone degeneration and continued distruction of the kidneys. Hyperphosphatemia unchecked will cause death.

4) How diet and supplementation have to do with any of this.

Under ideal conditions, reptiles would get
1) adequate natural light
2) a variety of food sources like their natural habitat offering all the nutrients and calories needed for growth, maintenance and reproduction.
If these conditions were met, there would be no need for UV lighting and supplementation…

That is not how it is however, so the ultimate question is how much and of what? Again, it is not that simple.

UVB lighting- If sufficient UVB lighting can be offered, this is a big step in naturally preventing MBD in an reptile housed inside. With the tubes and bulbs offered now a days, natural synthesis of D3 is the safest way of regulating calcium absorption. This assumes 1) there is adequate calcium in the diet, and 2) the bulb used is close enough for the animal to utilize and does not have significant burn out that causes less than optimal exposure to UVB.
This statement might lead an expert like Dr. Mader to suggest that supplementation may not be necessary.

Food items- Variety is more readily available these days, but still does not simulate the variety in the wild. Additionally, some of the staple feeders used are not adequate in the calciumhosphorus ratios. (Remember should be 2:1). Crickets, mealworms and superworms are actually the opposite ratio. Pheonix worms and butter worms are good in the ratio, but too high in fat.
This ratio in staple insects may be overcome by appropriate gut loading with appropriate legumes and greens and various formulated feeds. (Certain diets high in calcium has caused gut impaction in crickets.)

Finally supplementation- The jury is still out on the amount needed and the interaction between all the minerals and supplements.
Calcium with D3- if you have adequate UVB this should not be necessary. If D3 becomes too high it 1) messes up PTH regulation and 2) will cause hypercalcemia.
How good do you feel about your UVB bulb? If your bulb is no good, or your reptile refuses to bask close enough for it to be effective, maybe D3 is for you.
Calcium without D3- if the UVB is working, the ideally the body will take only what it needs. However, excess dietary calcium by itself may inhibit the absorption of other trace minerals. Too much is still not good.
Multivitamin- This is probably a better source of complete supplementation overall BUT- if you are giving insects that have an inverse ration of Ca, this may not be enough. Additionally, we still do not know the exact requirements for even the best research reptiles as of yet.

Summary- There is no easy answer. Try to know how the body systems work in your perspective reptile and understand that all of us are trying to work within our own varying restrictions (environmental, financial, availability, others). Shoot for a happy medium.

 

[MWheelock]

3

Sources- I highly encourage everyone to do their own research. This is merely a summary of facts that can be found through many sources. I paraphrased many of these sections from:
Reptile Medicine and Surgery, Mader
North American Veterinary Conference Procedings 2007
Speakers- Dr. Mader
Dr. Mark Mitchell- LSU
Dr. Fleming- Disney’s Animal Programs
Dr Pare- Toronto Zoo
My personal notes from veterinary school
Endocronology and Reproduction- Feldman and Nelson 3rd edition

I know that someone will ask what I am doing for my chams. So here it is. I have no real reason for this protocol other than it is similar to that used by some successful cham breeders.

I change my UVB lighting every 6 months. (probably unnecessary)
Gut-load with WER carrots, romaine, and orange
Juviniles Calcium w/o D3 twice a week
Multivitamin twice a week
Adults- Calcium w/o D3 once a week
Multivitamin once a month
Females (gravid) –Calcium w/o D3 twice a week
Multivitamin once to twice a week

I WOULD LOVE ANY AND ALL FEEDBACK.

 

[Brad Ramsey]

Dr. Mathew,
As I type this I am printing out your "rough draft" I cannot read and process such information on the computer.....I am taking my printout to bed with me for reading (it may help me sleep) and will be commenting on it later. I am certain to learn something tonight, and I have to say that this subject is fascinating to me. I hope to be a part of cracking the code!

-Brad

 

[cookiegirl]

mbd

I also feed my breeding female veileds one or two pinkie mice once a week. They love it. They get calcium from the bones. My male loves it too. I did not offer pinkie mice until they were at least 8 months old. The girls have successfuly laid 3 clutches of eggs so the pinkie mice along with gut loading the crickets and dusting must work. I find your article very interesting. It was my husbands ideal to feed them the pinkie mice. He called me into the room one day and said look at your chameleons and they were chomping down on the pinkie mice.

 

[Goliath]

Dr. Matthew,
We are so lucky to have you on this forum. Such a wealth of knowledge . Unfortunately my chameleon has MBD. I bought him on a whim and unfortunatley did not know much about these little fellows. I have learned alot though in the last few months from the forum and a breeder I ran into at the local petco. anyway, He has a deformity in his spine. He still has use of his back legs but sometimes I see him just hanging on a branch resting on his stomach with his back legs dangilin ( like a gymnast on a bar about to do a flip.) This can't be comfortable for him can it? He is healing and becoming stronger day by day though thanks to all of the helpful people on the forum and the vet. Well thanx for the info Matt.

 

[flpanther]

Excellent info.

My supplementation schedule is almost identical to yours. My chams are kept outdoors in natural sunlight(S. Florida)probably about 340-350 days a year. I agree with your supplement recommendations and also with your statement that D3 supplementation may be necessary for chams kept indoors who do not regularly bask close enough to the UVB tube. I am curious about how much D3 those of you who keep chams indoors up north use, mainly so I can provide good recommendations to the owners of my animals offspring, who may live further north and are not able to get thier chams outdoors often.

 

[Brad Ramsey]

I dust with D3 no more than once a week and herptevite supplement once every other week. I have a veiled so he also eats a decent amount of collards, kale and swiss chard (all high in calcium) and of course I gutload my feeders with as many dark greens as possible in addition to the other foods I feed the food.

-Brad

 

[MWheelock]

Goliath,

Thanks for the compliment. (You make me blush ....) As far as reptile medicine goes, I know a decent amount, but remember there are a large number of members on this forum with significantly more practical experience with various types of chams (much more than me ). Don't be afraid to use them.

As far as your little one, if you can get the MBD under control, you can expect a pretty normal life afterwards. He may not get any better than he already is, but sincehe doesn't have to escape predators, he'll do pretty well. As far as pain, I don't know. The jury is still out on how reptiles process pain. Grant you, they do feel pain, but how can you understand this when a lizard can get thermal burns by sitting on a active lightbulb (of its own accord.)

Talk to you later,
Matthew

 

[kinyonga]

Excellent write-up Dr. Wheelock!
If you talk to Dr. Pare, tell him Lynda says "hello"! He was my vet for quite a few years before he moved on to other "adventures". He's an excellent vet and we learned a lot together.

MWheelock said..."I know that someone will ask what I am doing for my chams. So here it is. I have no real reason for this protocol other than it is similar to that used by some successful cham breeders.

I change my UVB lighting every 6 months. (probably unnecessary)
Gut-load with WER carrots, romaine, and orange
Juviniles Calcium w/o D3 twice a week
Multivitamin twice a week
Adults- Calcium w/o D3 once a week
Multivitamin once a month
Females (gravid) –Calcium w/o D3 twice a week
Multivitamin once to twice a week"
I notice you use NO vitamin D3...do your chameleons get any direct sunlight? Is there any contained in the WER? (I'm not familiar with it.)
Does your multivitamin contain beta carotene or preformed vitamin A?
(I'm one of those people who's chameleons never get outdoors...and I dust lightly with D3/calcium twice a month.)

cookiegirl said..."I also feed my breeding female veileds one or two pinkie mice once a week. They love it. They get calcium from the bones. My male loves it too. I did not offer pinkie mice until they were at least 8 months old. The girls have successfuly laid 3 clutches of eggs so the pinkie mice along with gut loading the crickets and dusting must work"...one of the reasons I don't feed my chameleons pinkies any more is because a Parson's I had threw them up and they had been in his stomach for several days. They showed no signs of being digested and yet all the insects he ate for days before and days after (and even the ones that came up with the pinkies) were digested/digesting.

flpanther said..."I am curious about how much D3 those of you who keep chams indoors up north use, mainly so I can provide good recommendations to the owners of my animals offspring, who may live further north and are not able to get thier chams outdoors often"...as I said above, I dust lightly with calcium/D3 twice a month (in addition to my calcium, vitamin, gutloading, etc. schedules).

 

[Jordan]

I also feed my breeding female veileds one or two pinkie mice once a week. They love it. They get calcium from the bones. My male loves it too. I did not offer pinkie mice until they were at least 8 months old. The girls have successfuly laid 3 clutches of eggs so the pinkie mice along with gut loading the crickets and dusting must work. I find your article very interesting. It was my husbands ideal to feed them the pinkie mice. He called me into the room one day and said look at your chameleons and they were chomping down on the pinkie mice.

I would exercise caution with feeding that much protien to a chameleon. This could lead to a condition called gout. I personally have never used pinkies because of this concern. I would not think that feeding them on a less frequent basis would be bad. Veiled themselves have the widest variety diet of any of the chameleon that I know about. This would lead me to believe that they may have a some what more advanced digestive tract then some of the more strict insectivores.

 

[MWheelock]

Hey Kinyonga,

Yes my multivitamin contains Vit A, and betacartine among other things. I think the ratio that is of concern to me is of Vit A to Vit D to Vit E (and I don't remember the where these numbers came from, maybe Maders book) is 100:10:1.

As far as D3, I still haven't decided how much I'm going to use it. Since Manga is an adult, I have thought about using it every other calcium supplementation (every other week). He does not get any natural light, but I see him spend at least 45 minutes daily under his UVB bulb (<8" away). I figure (and I may be figuring wrong) he is getting what he needs with the UVB and regular calcium, BUT since secondary nutritional hyperparathyroidism is such a problem, and I don't have a reliable UVB sensor to see if there is UVB burnout, maybe I supplement every once in a while to keep the calcitriol levels on the high end of normal (whatever that is.)
I worry about supplementing it more than that since half-life of Calcitriol in a lot of animals is @ 72 hours. Since a reptiles metabolism is typically slower it may take longer to clear it from their system. If a reptile is colder that its optimal temperature level it may be even slower. For reasons stated before, I'm not so excited about oversupplementing.

How often should people supplement the growing and the pregnant? More often?....your guess is as good as mine.


As far as pinkies...some people swear by them...on the other hand if you are giving them for calcium supplementation, remember that these babies have incomplete skeletons- there bones are primarily cartilagenous precursers to bone, so are not so high in calcium. If the pinkie has just nursed, this may be gut-loaded with more calcium... I personally think that chameleons are insectivores and may only occassionaly have access to mammals in the wild. Variety is good, but I'd stick with a higher variety of insects.

Matthew

 

[kinyonga]

Can you comment more on why the vitamin E levels bother you, please?

Its definitely not easy to stay within "normal" (whatever that is, as you said) ranges for supplements. I would like to think that if the animal lives a long healthy life, can produce healthy babies that also live long healthy lives that whatever is being done for that animal must be somewhat "normal".

(Now I'm going to look up vitamin E to see what I can find out about it!)

 

[mczoo]

Thank you Dr. Wheelock for your review of supplimentation, Vitamins and their function. Is there a good resource to find research on these topics or is anyone actually done it yet.

 

[mczoo]

That last post did not sound right. What i mean is for example take several veileds from the same clutch and use different hour/types of light and no suppliment or use same lights and different suppliments and track next generation?? I know human research is generally lacking in quality when it comes to suppliments is chameleon research any better?
Thanks for all you input although i post little i read most of whats posted daily

Sean

 

[Netro]

I know that someone will ask what I am doing for my chams. So here it is. I have no real reason for this protocol other than it is similar to that used by some successful cham breeders.

I change my UVB lighting every 6 months. (probably unnecessary)
Gut-load with WER carrots, romaine, and orange
Juviniles Calcium w/o D3 twice a week
Multivitamin twice a week
Adults- Calcium w/o D3 once a week
Multivitamin once a month
Females (gravid) –Calcium w/o D3 twice a week
Multivitamin once to twice a week

I WOULD LOVE ANY AND ALL FEEDBACK.

Hello Dr. Wheelock. I'm a user of spanish chameleon forums a bit confuse lately about some aspects in the chameleon care. I never had to look in English forums, but now, I need more answers and I'll try to make an extra effort to write and read in English.

When talking about dusting the crickets for example, do you dust all of them? or just some of them?
When talking about Calcium, are you talking about a special calcium made for reptiles? or can be calcium carbonate??
When talking about Multivitamin, are you talking something like "reptivite"?

Thanks for your time and sorry for my English.

Toni.

 

[MWheelock]

My dusting protocol would be all the insects that one day would be lightly dusted (put into a bag with the calcium with D3) and given a good shake.
Crickets clean themselves off pretty quick so you would want to dust right before you feed.

Calcium carbonate is correct- you are looking for phosphorus free, so a reptile brand would probably be the safest bet. Remember, you can safely give calcium by itself 2-3 times a week, but it is the D3 that needs to be regulated.

Reptivite, herpivite,... there are a lot of multivitamins out there. Some better researched than others. I think that there is a tendency to oversupplement. I'm a big believer in giving more of a variety of feeders and giving the feeders more of a variety of veggies and grains themselves.

Good luck,
Matthew

 

[CleanLineChameleons]

Dr. Wheelock, awesome info! One thing I am wondering about is if the Wild Eyed Reptile gutload has any D3 in it (in the form of bone meal)? Also, I know your write up is about reptiles in general, but I have noticed that many of my gravid females tend to stay in the foliage after the first week and a half or two, that would mean that the calcium and multivitamins would increase in their bodies yet the D3 would not. Their requirements for calcium and D3 are already increased with the stress of eggs, let alone without as much UVB (from being in the foliage). Stacey mentioned that not only do growing children require more D3 than the common recommendation but so do aging adults, could this pertain to chameleons as well?

Thanks again for all your help Dr. Wheelock!!!

-Chris

 

[BocaJan]

Thank you Dr. Wheelock for your very informative recourse on calcium supplementation and the dreaded MBD. I hope that we hear more from you on various topics of interest regarding our chameleons.

 

[Netro]

Ok, thx Dr Wheelock. Let me share with all of you the schedules I've been using these last 2 years.

I've been doing this for more than one year:

Calcium carbonate 3-4 days per week in 2 feeders
Multivitamin twice a week in 2 feeders

Then, I started to use:

VIT-ALL in all the feeders all the days
MINER-ALL in all the feeders 3-4 days per week

Then, I moved to:

Reptivite twice per week in all the feeders
Calcium Carbonate twice per week in all the feeders
MINER-ALL twice per week in all the feeders

And finally, I'm doing:

Reptivite 4 days per week in all the feeders

All these schedules have been recomended by breeders, so, that's why I'm confuse...